This study was funded by the National Institute of Allergy and In

This study was funded by the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (1UC1AI062538-01) and Joint Science and Technology Office-Chemical, Biological Defense ((Plan1.1C0041_09_RD_B). We thank the aerobiology staff at USAMRIID for their contributions Dolutegravir mw to the aerosol challenge components of this study. “
“A safe and effective vaccine is an urgent substitutive approach to malaria control owing to the emergence and spread of drug-resistant strains and insecticide-resistant mosquito vectors [1], [2] and [3]. A Plasmodium falciparum chimeric protein

described as PfCP-2.9 [4] and [5] has been constructed as an anti-malaria vaccine candidate which is composed of two leading vaccine candidate antigens against blood-stage parasites; the 19 kDa carboxyl-terminal region of Merozoite Surface Protein 1 (MSP1-19) [6], [7], [8], [9] and [10] and domain III of the Apical Membrane Antigen 1 (AMA-1 [III]) of P. falciparum [11] and [12]. PfCP-2.9 was produced in Pichia pastoris

with an extremely high yield (2.6 g/l). Recombinant PfCP-2.9 adjuvanted with Montanide ISA720 which has been used in the clinical trials of malaria and HIV vaccines [13], [14], [15] and [16] revealed enhanced immunogenicity and antibody-mediated inhibition of parasite growth in vitro compared to its individual components in various animal models. Phase I trials of the PfCP-2.9 vaccine candidate have been completed [17]. The stability and potency of vaccine formulations are an important issue during the vaccine development, GW786034 clinical trial particularly for emulsion with Montanide ISA720 that is impossibly frozen. ISA720 was shown to elicit higher anti-PfCP-2.9 antibody titers than several other adjuvants tested in animals [data not shown]. One concern, however, was the fact that Montanide ISA720 has been reported to modify antigens following the emulsion process which may result in loss of potency [16]. In addition, the PfCP-2.9 protein contains 18 cysteine residues, six located in AMA-1(III) domain and the rest in the MSP1-19

domain which form nine intramolecular disulfide bonds whose tertiary structure is critical to PfCP-2.9 unless immunogenicity [18] and [19]. Sera from rabbits immunized with denatured PfCP-2.9 lost its inhibition effect on parasite growth and the antibody response decreased dramatically (unpublished data). In this study, we developed a sandwich ELISA-based method to assess the nature of the adjuvanted PfCP-2.9 over time in addition to determining its integrity and capacity to elicit immune response in an animal model using available assessments. Six-to-eight-week old, female, BALB/c mice and 4–6-month old, male, New Zealand rabbits were purchased from the Shanghai Laboratory Animal Center of Chinese Academy Sciences. All animals were maintained in the experimental animal care facility of the Second Military Medical University. The P.

The delayed TPm crystal growth seen in the CARS dissolution imagi

The delayed TPm crystal growth seen in the CARS dissolution imaging (Fig. 8) was expected to affect the TPa dissolution rate and Fig. 9 shows that this was the case. Fig. 9 shows the dissolution profiles for TPa and TPm compacts undergoing dissolution using MC solution as the dissolution medium. From Fig. 9 it can be seen that the

characteristic decrease in dissolution rate associated with TPm growth on the surface of TPa compacts (Fig. 7) is no longer seen. Instead the TPa compacts reach a concentration of about 150 μg/mL and remain there for the duration of the experiment. The dissolution behavior of the TPm compacts appear minimally affected by the use of the MC dissolution medium as

they reach a concentration of about 80 μg/mL and remain there for the duration of the experiment. This concentration is the same GSK126 research buy as was observed for water without the polymer, revealing that the solubility of the drug is not affected by the polymer in solution, and therefore the different dissolution profiles obtained with and without polymer solution are not solubility mediated. The steady-state intrinsic dissolution rates were calculated to be 700 ± 130 μg/min/cm2 and 350 ± 40 μg/min/cm2 for the compacts prepared from TPa and TPm respectively (assuming both compacts had a perfectly planar surface). Since the solubility of the TPa is twice that of TPm in water at 25 °C [29], a two-fold increase in the dissolution rate of the compact prepared from TPa would theoretically only be expected if there were check details no conversion to the monohydrate. However, an increase in surface area of the compacts prepared from TPa after TPm formation was observed in water which affected the dissolution behavior, and therefore a surface area increase can also be expected to affect Resveratrol the dissolution profiles

in the polymer solution. Additionally, from Fig. 9 there are noticeable fluctuations in the steady-state concentrations (when compared to Fig. 7) of both TPa and TPm this is attributed to bubbles in the dissolution medium not removed by sonication. The inherent confocality, chemical specificity, and speed provided by CARS microscopy increases the spatial and chemical resolution of the system providing advantages over existing approaches including traditional optical microscopy and Raman microscopy based on spontaneous Raman scattering. The biggest advantage when compared to traditional optical microscopy is the fact that the detected signal is generated when the excitation beams match the Raman vibrational mode for the chemical of interest this provides chemical selectivity. If the excitation laser frequencies are incorrect or the sample is the wrong chemical then no resonant signal is generated.

One of the most important aspects arising from the study was the

One of the most important aspects arising from the study was the difficulty to retrieve data about both direct and indirect costs; their evaluation would have allowed us to consider the social impact of vaccination and not only the National Health Service perspective. This could represent the most important limit

of our analysis NVP-BGJ398 order together with the use of international data about utilities. It should be added moreover that this analysis was preliminary in assessing clinical and economic impact of HPV vaccine because was made using epidemiology, cost and vaccine efficacy data available in 2007. Nevertheless the values used are now confirmed and reinforced by the new evidences on epidemiology and vaccine efficacy [45], and the evidence was gathered in several HTA report in different countries [46], [47], [48], [49] and [50]. Nevertheless some strength clearly emerges from our study: the thoroughness of the evaluation allowed us accounting for all the aspects of HPV infection/diseases. For example the survey showed that selleck kinase inhibitor informative and educative campaigns should be carried out to improve knowledge of women about STDs. Anyway, women showed to be very interested in receiving the HPV vaccine. This let us able to consider also citizens’ perspective on this hot topic which has been faced in different ways by social and religious movements.

In conclusion, this first attempt to standardise the HTA application to the new field of vaccines led us to establish that HPV vaccines, and in particular bivalent HPV vaccine, could have a great impact on population being on the whole cost-effective. Moreover, the project arose questions and challenges about the standardisation of HTA methods and the improvement of research, and highlighted

the need for a continuing process of HTA production given the updated increase of evidence in this field. “
“Prior to the implementation of routine varicella vaccination, important concerns were raised. Firstly, vaccination could lead to a shift in the average age at infection from children to adults where risk of complication is greater. The worry was that, by increasing incidence in adults, varicella vaccination programs could lead to and an overall reduction in public health. Mathematical models however predicted that this was unlikely to happen [1]. Secondly, there were concerns related to the high number of varicella cases in vaccinees in the clinical trials [2], [3], [4] and [5]. Thirdly, there were concerns that vaccination could increase the incidence of zoster. It has long been hypothesized that exposure to varicella might reduce the risk of reactivation (zoster) by boosting specific immunity to the Varicella Zoster Virus (VZV) [6]. Two epidemiological studies have suggested that this mechanism plays an important role in protection against zoster [7] and [8].

i All animals survived to the end of the experiment (Table 2, Fi

i. All animals survived to the end of the experiment (Table 2, Fig. 2A). Mice immunised with VP2D1 + VP2D2, or VP2D1 + VP2D2 + VP5Δ1–100 of BTV-4, but challenged with BTV-8, showed signs of infection by day 3 p.i., and all had died by day 5 p.i (Fig. 2C). Ct values of 20.7–22.4, and virus titres

calculated by plaque assay were 7 × 103–2 × 104 pfu/ml on day 4 p.i. selleck inhibitor In contrast, time of death was delayed (day 5–7 p.i. [P < 0.05]) by addition of VP7 to this immunisation regime (BTV-4 VP2D1 + VP2D2 + VP5Δ1–100 + VP7) ( Fig. 2C), with Ct values on day 5 p.i. of 22.4–23.7 (virus titres calculated by plaque assay: 3 × 103–7 × 103 pfu/ml, Fig. 2D). The two non-immunised control-groups, challenged with BTV-4(italy03), or BTV-8(BTV-8-28) were all positive by RT-PCR on day 3 p.i. and all died by day 5 p.i. (Fig. 2A and C) with Ct values 20.9–22.7. Virus was successfully isolated from these animals on both KC cells and BSR (BSR plaque assay titres: 5 × 103–3 × 104 pfu/ml (Fig. 2B and D)). Animals in the group immunised with VP5Δ1–100 were not challenged because initial studies with Balb/c mice

showed that sera of mice immunised with VP5Δ1–100 only, did not neutralise virus infectivity. All animals in the groups immunised with VP7 only, died by day 5 p.i. with levels of BTV-specific RNA in blood similar to http://www.selleckchem.com/products/DAPT-GSI-IX.html non-immunised mice (BSR plaque assay titres: 4 × 103–2.7 × 104 pfu/ml). This suggests that increased survival times of mice immunised with VP2D1 + VP2D2 + VP5Δ1–100 + VP7 is not due to VP7 alone, but may be an effect of combining these different proteins. Several inactivated mono- and multivalent vaccines for BTV serotypes 1, 2, 4 or 8, have been authorised via the European Medicines Agency for use in ruminants, particularly cattle and sheep [41] and [42]. These relatively un-purified vaccine antigens raise antibodies to all virus structural and non-structural proteins, making it found impossible to distinguish infected from vaccinated animals (DIVA) by serological

assays. Previous studies exploring recombinant-expressed BTV structural proteins as subunit-vaccine candidates have evaluated crude lysates of recombinant-baculovirus-infected insect cells expressing BTV VP2 and VP5 [43], [44] and [45]. Immunisation of sheep with these proteins, protected the animals and raised significant NAb titres (up to 2.408), with transient or undetectable viraemia after a subsequent homologous-BTV challenge [43]. Recently, it was shown that baculovirus-expressed and purified VP2 induced neutralising antibodies [45] and is stable at +4 °C as well as −80 °C for almost 2 years [46]. Immunisation with virus-like particles (VLPs) containing capsid-proteins (VP3, VP7, VP2 and VP5) also protected sheep and raised NAbs (titres of upto 2.

In general

inactivated whole virion vaccines are more imm

In general

inactivated whole virion vaccines are more immunogenic than split/subunit vaccines [56]. However, it has been shown that whole virion vaccines may be more effective without an additional adjuvant [57], and it was mentioned that the neutralizing activity of an adjuvanted whole virion H5N1 vaccine was lower than that of an adjuvanted split-virion H5N1 vaccine [58]. The intratracheal route of virus inoculation establishes a reproducible severe pneumonia in the ferret model [36]. Ferrets immunized with nasal Endocine™ formulated vaccines, but not ferrets immunized with parenteral TIV were protected from severe pneumonia. Protection from pneumonia corresponded with the absence of detectable virus replication in the lung and absent or significantly reduced virus replication in the upper respiratory tract. Also the previously developed CT-scanning [14], [15], [28] and [29], confirmed

that nasal Endocine™ formulated signaling pathway vaccine, but not parenteral TIV protected the ferrets from severely affected and selleck chemicals llc inflamed lungs and marked alterations in ALVs. Current candidate influenza vaccine design has a strong focus on mucosal immunity and the crucial role of mucosal adjuvants in the development of effective inactivated or subunit nasal vaccines [14], [15], [16], [17] and [18]. Adjuvanted nasal vaccines may have the advantage to induce systemic as well as mucosal immunity, including specific secretory IgA (S-IgA) [6]. Locally produced antibodies, particularly S-IgA have been demonstrated to play an important role in responses to natural infection. Pre-existing S-IgA antibodies can prevent infection by neutralizing

influenza virus before it passes the mucosal barrier, can out effectively prevent infection of epithelial cells and have been shown to contribute to the establishment of cross-protection [59]. In the present ferret study, nasal wash and swab samples were collected for detection of antibodies against influenza. Interestingly, the nasal wash procedure clearly yielded higher antibody titers than the nasal cotton swabs. Endocine™ formulated split antigen (15 μg HA) induced significantly (p < 0.05) higher nasal Ig titers in nasal wash samples after two immunizations compared to the parenteral vaccine (manuscript in preparation). Furthermore, the present study showed that the Endocine™ formulated inactivated pH1N1/09 influenza vaccines administered nasally induced broad specific systemic antibody responses in naïve ferrets. The Endocine™ formulated split antigen (15 μg HA) vaccine induced cross reactive HI antibody titers of >40 (GMT) against distant viruses of swine origin already after one immunization and both HI and VN cross reactive titers>200 (GMT) was achieved after two immunizations. Overall this study shows the feasibility to induce protective systemic immunity after intranasal administration of relatively low doses inactivated pH1N1/09 antigens when formulated with Endocine™.

Specifically, approximately 10 h after

Specifically, approximately 10 h after Adriamycin purchase receipt of a 60-μg dose of rLP2086 vaccine, Prevenar®, Infanrix hexa®, Meningitec®, and Rotarix®, the subject developed

a fever (39.0 °C). A lumbar puncture was performed, and initial results showed 500 cells (95% PMNs), protein 0.5 mg/dl (normal), glucose 60 mg/dl (normal), and red blood cell count of 10 mm3. The subject was treated with cefotaxime and vancomycin after the lumbar puncture; the fever cleared by the next evening and the child remained afebrile and well. The workup did not identify a causative organism; blood and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) bacterial and viral cultures were negative; polymerase chain reaction tests of the ABT 199 CSF were also negative. Although the aseptic meningitis was ultimately considered not vaccine related by the treating physician, review of safety data by a project-independent safety committee revealed 80% of vaccine recipients at the 60-μg dose experienced

mild to moderate fever (90% including the case of aseptic meningitis). The sponsor decided to terminate the trial after the vaccine was deemed not acceptable in this population. Forty-six subjects were randomized: 22 received 20 μg rLP2086, 10 received 60 μg rLP2086, and 14 received routine childhood vaccines only. Mean age was 65.5 days; 48% were girls; all were white. All subjects received 1 vaccine dose; no postvaccination blood samples were drawn. At least

1 local reaction was reported for 11 (50%) subjects in the 20-μg group, 7 (70%) subjects in the 60-μg group, and 5 (36%) subjects in the control group. The rates of all reactions, except erythema, were lowest in the control group and highest in the 60-μg group (Table 1). The most common local reaction was tenderness, with a mean duration of 1.3 days, 2.7 days, and 1.0 day in the 20-μg, 60-μg, and control groups, respectively. Five subjects receiving rLP2086 experienced tenderness that interfered with limb movement. Most subjects experienced ≥1 systemic event. The most common event was irritability, reported for 17 (77%), 9 (90%), and 9 (64%) subjects in the 20-μg, 60-μg, and control groups. Rates of the other systemic reactions mafosfamide and anti-pyretic medication use were lowest in the control group and highest in the 60-μg group, with the exception of decreased sleep (Table 1). Duration of events was 1.0–3.3 days. Fever ≥38 °C was reported in the majority of rLP2086 vaccine recipients: 14 (64%) in the 20-μg group and 8 (80%) in the 60-μg group compared with 4 (29%) in the control group (Fig. 2). In most cases, the temperature was 38.0–39.0 °C; 2 subjects in the 20-μg group and 1 subject in the 60-μg group had fever of >39.0–40.0 °C. No fevers were >40.0 °C. The mean duration of fever was 1.0–2.1 days. The subject with aseptic meningitis also reported a fever between >39.0 and 40.

05 were considered significant (* = p < 0 05) The erythroid diff

05 were considered significant (* = p < 0.05). The erythroid differentiation of

K562 cells was investigated after the treatment with six FK228 chemical structure psoralens and five angelicins, whose structures are described in Fig. 1. K652 cells were irradiated with two UV-A doses (1 and 2 J/cm2) and then erythroid differentiation was measured by benzidine test after 5, 6 and 7 days from irradiation. At the same time, cellular viability was evaluated by MTT, obtaining evidences suggesting antiproliferative effects and phototoxicity. Different concentrations of compounds were employed because of their different phototoxic effects; accordingly, concentrations were chosen to maximize the erythroid effect without extensive reduction of cell viability. Moreover, considering the fact that some angelicins were powerful γ-globin inducers without irradiation [26], the same tests were performed with higher concentration Selleckchem HDAC inhibitor of furocumarins in the absence of irradiation. With the exception of 4,6,4′-trimethylangelicin (4,6,4′-TMA) [26], without irradiation all furocoumarins, when administered at 50 μM, showed a very low capability

of causing an increase of benzidine positive cells (lower than 10%) with respect to control (data not shown). On the contrary, after irradiation all tested molecules were able to induce a clear increase of benzidine positive cells, as displayed in Table 1. Table 1 reports the next percentages of benzidine positive cells and cellular viability after 6 days after irradiation at the highest concentration for each compound. In general, psoralens induced a higher proportion of erythroid differentiating cells (38.4–78.1%) in comparison to angelicins (24.3–58.7%), and these data confirmed the ones obtained with other furocoumarins [7]. Furthermore, the

induction of erythroid differentiation was dependent on the UV-A dose with the exception of some cases in which the antiproliferative effect was a major effect (see for example 5,5′-dimethylpsoralen or 4,6,4′-TMA or 4,4′,5′-trimethylangelicin). In the panel A of Fig. 2, the concentration-dependent increase of the ratio of benzidine positive cells was illustrated for some compounds as examples. Moreover, the panel B of Fig. 2 shows representative pictures of treated cells after benzidine staining: cells irradiated in the presence of 4′,5′-dimethylpsoralen (4′,5′-DMP) clearly were blue-colored1 and became larger with respect to control (this effect is not unusual within already reported inducers of erythroid differentiation, such as cytosine arabinoside [10]). Further experiments were carried out to determine whether the induced erythroid differentiation was reversible. To this aim, 6 days after irradiation (1 J/cm2), K562 cells were incubated for additional 4 days with fresh medium, and the benzidine test was performed at this point.


“Streptococcus pyogenes causes diseases as pharyngitis, im


“Streptococcus pyogenes causes diseases as pharyngitis, impetigo, streptococcal toxic shock syndrome and necrotizing fasciitis. Rheumatic fever (RF), acute streptococcal glomerulonephritis and rheumatic heart disease (RHD) are non-suppurative autoimmune post-streptococcal sequelae that arise from a delayed immune response to infection in genetically predisposed individuals [1]. Several markers are described as risk factors for RF/RHD, including HLA-DR7,

the allele most commonly associated with RHD in Brazil and other countries [2]. Cell Cycle inhibitor According to the World Health Organization (WHO), S. pyogenes is responsible for 15–20% of bacterial pharyngitis cases, which primarily affect 5- to 18-year-old individuals [3]. The incidence of bacterial pharyngitis varies among countries, and even within the same country, there are variations in different regions due to age, socioeconomic and environmental factors and quality of health services [4] and [5]. The M protein has been described as the major bacterial antigen [6]. The protein consists of two polypeptide chains in an alpha double helix coiled-coil that forms fibrils extending up to 60 nm away from the bacterial surface. It is approximately 450 amino acids long

and is divided into tandem repeat blocks distributed over four regions (A, B, C and D). The N-terminal portion (regions A and B) is polymorphic and differences within the first 150 amino acid residues of the A region allow for the classification of different serotypes [7] and [8]. The C-terminal portion (regions C and D) is highly conserved, responsible for binding the bacteria to the oropharynx SP600125 clinical trial mucosa and has antiphagocytic properties [6] and [7]. RF/RHD pathogenesis is related to the production of autoantibodies and autoreactive T cells that recognize and cross-react with epitopes from both the M protein and human heart tissue by molecular mimicry [9] and [10] and it was demonstrated by analyzing the T cell repertoire that infiltrated cardiac tissue and led to damage in RHD

[11]. M1 is the most common strain worldwide and, due to its high virulence, Adenosine is involved in invasive and non-invasive infections in several countries [12] and [13]. There is a large diversity of strains in Brazil. The most prevalent strains found in a sample from Sao Paulo city were the M1, M6, M12, M22, M77 and M87 compatible with those found in the rich districts from Salvador [5] and [14]. These M-types are also predominant in most of the world western countries [15]. Besides that, there is a much higher diversity of M-types in the poor districts from Salvador and Brasilia typically found in low incomes regions [5] and [16]. The classification of strains according to their tissue tropism for throat (A–C pattern), skin (D pattern) or both (E pattern) is based on the organization of emm and emm-like genes located in the mga locus within S. pyogenes genome and constitute the base for emm pattern genotyping [17] and [18].

It has been demonstrated that the level of cross-reactivity and c

It has been demonstrated that the level of cross-reactivity and cross-protection among PspAs correlates NVP-BKM120 purchase with sequence similarity, being low between PspAs of different families and higher within each family. Furthermore, it has been suggested that the level of cross-reactivity and cross-protection varies depending on the PspA clade

[21]. In that study, a PspA from clade 3 elicited antibodies with the lowest cross-reaction, while PspAs 4 and 5 (belonging to family 2) were highly cross-reactive. For family 1 molecules, neither PspA clade 1 nor clade 2 were able to induce antibodies cross-reactive to all family 1 strains tested. Therefore, further research was needed to better understand cross-reactivity within family 1. In the present study, the N-terminal regions of five clade 1 and five clade 2 PspAs were produced, antibodies generated and screened for their cross-reactivity against a panel of Brazilian strains containing clade 1 and 2 PspAs. The immunoblot analysis revealed a high heterogeneity in the level of cross-reactivity of the different antisera; while most cross-reacted mainly within the homologous clade, four PspAs – 245/00, M12, 94/01 and P339 – generated antibodies able to recognize most of the isolates tested. There was selleck compound no predominance between the PspA clade and the level of cross-reaction;

clades 1 and 2 were equally cross-reactive. The hybridization of the reverse primers in distinct regions within the proline-rich moiety generated fragments with different sizes; all fragments included the entire alfa-helical domain plus the beginning of the proline-rich region, and some were longer, containing most of the proline block, several including the nonproline block. Although there was no clear correlation between the size of the fragment and the level of cross-reactivity by immunoblot – the most cross-reactive fragments included

both long and short proteins – in the more stringent assays – complement deposition and OPA – the two best candidates included the proline-rich region with the nonproline block. This result suggests a possible role for the proline-rich region with the nonproline block in the induction of functional antibodies. This data is in agreement with a recent study demonstrating that immunization of mice with the proline-rich Oxymatrine region including the nonproline block was able to protect mice against fatal challenge [28]. Complement mediated antibody-dependent phagocytosis is considered to be an important mechanism of pneumococcal clearance [29]. The ability of anti-PspA antibodies to promote complement deposition on the bacterial surface greatly contributes to their protective effect [11]. It has been demonstrated, however, that the level of complement deposited depends on the similarity between the PspA used to induce the antibodies and that expressed by the pneumococcus [21] and [30].

This field-level data is a key component in ensuring the policy c

This field-level data is a key component in ensuring the policy changes and licensing sought are compatible with country needs and conditions. Assessment of the vaccine usability was based on the status of the VVM on the OPV vials. Laboratory studies and field studies conducted mainly in India have shown good correlation Stem Cell Compound Library chemical structure between the OPV potency (level of active ingredient) and the VVM stage following exposure of the vaccine to heat [7], [8] and [9]. Nevertheless, in order to obtain certainty that the vaccines delivered during these NIDs did in fact retain the assumed potency levels, a study measuring the remaining virus content levels would be required. The sample selection

was based on convenience, taking into account the logistical and practical constraints of organising the study. Nevertheless, the four health areas that participated are a likely good representation of the six areas of the Sélingué

district selected for the investigation. They cover more than half of the geographical area and inhabitants of the district. During this study, teams had the opportunity to use and experience both methods. This way, each vaccination team performed as its own comparison group Selleck CB-839 for the two procedures that were applied, preventing a potential systematic difference between OCC/CC groups. The teams were therefore aware of the purpose and objective of investigation. Consequently, it is possible that there was a systematic difference in the perceptions of the participants concerning the new method introduced. The risk

of respondent bias, i.e. participants responding what they think will please the interviewers, was reduced by a neutral and independent approach to data collection [13]. Questions were phrased and administered in an impartial way, and there was no judgement or incentive related to responses. Furthermore, the weight Dipeptidyl peptidase reduction through the OCC procedure, which was the main reason for vaccinators to prefer this procedure, is undisputable. Nevertheless, a small element of respondent bias in this more qualitative part of the study cannot be fully excluded. One of the main concerns in planning the study was ensuring that none of the vaccines administered had an expired VVM. To prevent this from happening, prior training was conducted and supervision during the vaccination activities was assured. Further, the teams only used the polio vials kept outside of the cold chain for one day at a time (whereas stability data indicate that OPV can remain stable at 37 °C for 2 days). These precautions proved effective, as evidenced by the fact that at the time the last dose of each vial was administered the VVM stage was always reported to be acceptable. The VVMs were read and classified by the vaccinators, and not by a densitometer, which theoretically provides room for human error.